US flag US

Tonies

How We Increased Tonies' Revenue by 94% YoY Whilst Still Keeping Their Commission Below 6%

For those with only 30 seconds, this is what we achieved:

  • We achieved a 94% year-over-year (YoY) increase in revenue, growing from £2.4 million to £4.8 million, with only a 6% increase in commission spend.
  • Implementing product-level tracking to optimize commission structures, led to £1 million in revenue from Tonieboxes alone.
  • We secured standout results for key partners, including an 11% increase in AOV for TopCashback and 121% YoY revenue growth for The Independent.

Big Results!

Our efforts increased revenue YoY by

+94% +94%

We also saw an uplift in orders by

+103% +103%

Who is Tonies?

Tonies is a revolutionary audio system designed for children, combining engaging storytelling with imaginative play. Their product line includes Tonieboxes which are durable, child-friendly audio players – and a wide range of Tonies figurines that bring beloved stories and songs to life. With a focus on simplicity, creativity, and high-quality content, Tonies has become a favourite among families worldwide.

What was the challenge?

Tonies has strong potential within the affiliate space but their program needed to be refined and optimized to allow for scalable growth. In order to move up the Silverbean progression model, we identified key areas for improvement:

  • The program overall needed a deep audit, with inactive or low-value partners removed. 
  • A lack of product-level tracking limited insights into how different products were performing across partners. 
  • The commission structure was not fully optimized, leading to inefficiencies in budget allocation. 
  • Growth was being limited by outdated tracking and data limitations, preventing more sophisticated strategic decisions. 

To overcome these challenges, we needed to revise, reassess and restructure the program. Laying the foundations for a more efficient and scalable affiliate strategy. 

What was our solution?

Over a 12 month period, we implemented a structured, phased approach to transform the affiliate program. 

Phase 1: Affiliate Program Audit & Publisher Review

The first step was an in-depth audit of the entire affiliate program, ensuring that we were working with the right partners. We meticulously assessed each publisher based on performance, engagement and alignment with Tonies’ objectives. 

  • Removed over 80 affiliates that were inactive, low value, or no longer fit for purpose.
  • Created a tiered prioritisation system, ranking partners based on their potential impact. 
  • Reduced commission across underperforming publishers, reallocating budget to those delivering higher value. 

This audit cleaned up the program, making it leaner and more effective. With a solid foundation in place, we were ready to move forward with more advanced optimisations. 

Phase 2: Implementing Product Level Tracking

With the Tonies tech team, we introduced product level tracking, which became a game changer. Previously, all sales were traced at a generic level, making it difficult to distinguish between Toniesboxes (high value, high AOV) and Tonies Characters (lower value, high volume). 

  • The new tracking allowed us to segment performance by product type, helping us refine our commission strategy. 
  • We could now see which bundles were performing best and adjust promotions accordingly.
  • The tracking also gave insights into stock levels, allowing us to boost commissions strategically to clear older stock and make way for new launches.

Phase 3: Flexing Commission to Maximize Revenue & Efficient

With product level tracking in place, we restructured the commission model to make budget allocation more efficient. 

  • Lowered CPA for Tonies Characters to 1-2% to prevent excessive commission spend on lower value items. 
  • Increased commission for Toniesboxes encouraging affiliates to drive more high value sales.
  • Partnered closely with key affiliates to test different commission levels based on product type and AOV.

This data driven commission structure ensured that the budget was spent where it delivered the most value, allowing us to significantly scale revenue without a corresponding surge in commission costs.

What Results Were Achieved?

By implementing a structured, data led strategy, we transformed the Tonies affiliate program into a more efficient, high performing channel. 

  • 94% YoY revenue growth, increased from 2.4M to £4.8M, while keeping commission growth to just 6% – demonstrating significant cost savings. Without the new commission structure, spend would have been expected to rise in line with revenue, but the optimized approach allowed for substantial growth without a proportional increase in costs.
  • Orders increased by 103% YoY, reflecting stronger customer acquisition and conversion strategies.
  • £1M in revenue generated purely from Toniesboxes, demonstrating the power of strategic commission incentives in shifting high value products.
  • 18,570 Tonieboxes were sold in 2024 since product tracking was implemented, generating £1,208,738 in revenue, reinforcing the success of category specific incentives.
  • In the second half of 2024, spend actually fell by 0.44% YoY, while sales increased by 98.39% and revenue by 87.02% YoY, highlighting the continued efficiency of the program.
  • In the months following the restructure, the contribution of Toniesboxes to overall revenue increased, showing that customers were converting because of the higher commission rate offered for purchasing a Toniebox. This was reflected in a steady rise in Toniebox revenue contribution, from 22% in April to 28% in May, 31% in June and 35% in October.
  • 73% YoY increase in order-active partners from 2023 to 2024, highlighting the impact of the team’s audit and optimisation efforts. 

Key partner successes:

  • TopCashback’s AOV increased by 11.27% month-on-month to £85.46, which is £10 higher than the program average. 
  • The Independent saw a 121% YoY revenue increase, showing the impact of enhanced content partnerships.
  • 16 secured article inclusions, with 8 being evergreen, ensuring long term SEO value and sustained traffic. 
  • Blue Light Card generated £1.1M in revenue, marking an 85% YoY increase, marking it the highest performing closed user group partner for Tonies. 
  • There was an increase in Toniebox sales from Reward Gateway (+36% PoP) and Blue Light Card (+20% PoP) after the initial test in June, showcasing the impact of strategic commission incentives. 

Beyond immediate revenue growth, these strategic optimisations have elevated Tonies’ position within the affiliate channel, moving the program up the Silverbean progression model, from a growth/proactive growth stage in January 2023 to an advanced growth stage by January 2025. 

With this foundation in place the team is now positioned to focus more on new customer acquisitions, potentially implementing new vs. existing tracking to refine targeting and attribution further. Over time, there are plans to adjust commission structure further, particularly around Tonie characters, potentially phasing outs for them altogether. Additionally, the program’s success has enabled Tonies to start exploring additional regions, ensuring long term scalability and market growth.

Key Takeaways

This case study highlights the power of a structured, data and tech driven approach to affiliate program management:

  • Program audits are essential – clearing out inefficiencies allows for smarter growth.
  • Product level tracking unlocks powerful insights, enabling more strategic decision making
  • Smart commission structures drive efficiency, increasing revenue without inflating costs.
  • Leveraging data allows brands to scale effectively, ensuring budget is spent where it delivers the most impact. 

Tonies’ success proves that with the right tech, strategic commission adjustments and a proactive approach, brands can significantly scale revenue while keeping affiliate costs in check. This case study serves as a blueprint for how optimising the fundamentals can unlock exponential growth.

With the right strategy, the team transformed Tonies program into a high performing, scalable channel - and so can you. Whether you’re looking to drive revenue growth, optimise commission structures or expand into new markets, we can help. 

← Previous View all work Next →